Lemonade
Lemonade
Alternatives

13 Lemonade Alternatives with Special Offers in February

Top 3 Picks: Compare for Amazing Offers

Top Pick
8.6
Progressive
Progressive View Deals
Featured
8.5
Geico
Geico View Deals
Featured
8.2
Allstate
Allstate View Deals

Comparing Lemonade alternatives could lead to better value, prices, and customer service. We've identified 13 alternatives that might be the perfect fit for your needs. Take a look and see how these brands can offer more.

Suggested Comparisons Updated on Feb 18, 2026

Lemonade Alternatives

1
Progressive
Top Pick
8.6

Progressive

Bundling Large Carrier Online Quotes
2
Geico
Featured
8.5

Geico

Low Rates Focus Online Quotes Large Carrier
3
Allstate
Featured
8.2

Allstate

Agent Network Large Carrier Bundling
4
State Farm
8.4

State Farm

Agent Network Large Carrier Bundling
5
Nationwide Insurance
8.0

Nationwide Insurance

Bundling Large Carrier Multi Product
6
Liberty Mutual
8.1

Liberty Mutual

Online Purchase Large Carrier Bundling
7
USAA
8.7

USAA

Military Only High Service Bundling
8
AAA | American Automobile Association
7.6

AAA | American Automobile Association

Membership Regional Availability Bundling
9
Hippo
8.0

Hippo

Digital First Homeowners Focus Fast Quotes
10
Toggle
7.8

Toggle

Digital First Customizable Backed By Carrier
11
Farmers Insurance
8.1

Farmers Insurance

Agent Network Large Carrier Bundling
12
Travelers
7.9

Travelers

Agent Sold Large Carrier Home Focus
13
Amica
8.3

Amica

Direct High Service Home Focus
How We Rank These Brands?

Our rankings are meticulously determined through a point system that considers a comprehensive set of criteria that includes:

Customer Service

Customer Service

We evaluate support coverage and quality: checking for live chat and real customer satisfaction

Brand's Rating

Brand's Rating

An overall score combining verified customer reviews, third-party trust ratings and complaint/return ratios.

Popularity

Popularity

A measure of consumer interest based on website traffic, search trends, social engagement, and growth momentum.